FITZHUGH URBAN FLATS

4702 HOMER ST, DALLAS, TX, 75204

APARTMENT (BRICK EXTERIOR) Garden 176 units Built 2007 3 stories ★ 4.2 (177 reviews) 🚶 73 Very Walkable 🚌 57 Good Transit 🚲 65 Bikeable

$40,505,340

2025 Appraised Value

↑ 14.3% from prior year

📍 This parcel is part of the FITZHUGH URBAN FLATS community — scraped data shown is for the full community.

FITZHUGH URBAN FLATS – INVESTMENT OVERVIEW

The $177.3M debt stack against a $40.5M appraised value represents a critical refinance risk: dual 2020 MISC tranches likely already matured, the primary Walker & Dunlop loan matures ~2025, and aggressive $1.01M debt-per-unit leverage will strain cash flow at current rates—signaling near-term seller motivation tied to refinancing pressure rather than value-add optionality. Market fundamentals are mixed: the 1-mile radius's 22.0% affordability ratio caps rent growth without tenant displacement, but the 3-mile commute-shed ($120.3K median income, 18.9% affordability) offers deeper demand, and a 56-unit pipeline (31.8% of supply) delivering through 2026–27 will extend near-term vacancy headwinds. On the asset side, one-third of the 176-unit portfolio remains in original 2007 condition, with 8–12% NOI accretion available from kitchen/flooring standardization and laundry rollout across non-renovated units; the Walk Score of 73 and Class B+ amenity package support young professional positioning, though a Transit Score of 57 indicates hybrid car-dependent tenancy that limits rent premium relative to truly transit-rich Dallas peers. The wide divergence between appraised value ($40.5M) and assumed sale price ($87.9M) requires immediate validation on acquisition underwriting. Watch-list only: debt maturity risk and supply pressure are near-term headwinds that favor a distressed entry point; pass at stabilized multiples pending debt resolution and pipeline absorption.

AI overview · Updated 21 days ago
Abstract Notes

No notes yet

Interior Finishes & Renovation Status:
Fitzhugh shows selective unit upgrades post-2007, with evidence of 2016-2020 modernization across roughly two-thirds of the 176-unit portfolio. Mixed flooring (hardwood, vinyl plank) and isolated white painted cabinetry with modern slab styling suggest a partial, unit-by-unit capital plan rather than a comprehensive repositioning. The presence of in-unit washer/dryer in select units signals inconsistent amenity distribution.

Exterior & Amenities:
Contemporary mid-rise architecture with clean finishes and resort-style pool/spa complex positions the property at the Class B+ tier. The curated amenity space (heated pool, separate spa, landscaped courtyard) suggests deliberate Class A positioning, though the 2007 build date and partial interior refresh create a mixed-vintage asset profile.

Value-Add Potential:
Approximately one-third of units remain in original 2007 condition based on photo distribution. Standardizing kitchen finishes, flooring, and in-unit laundry across non-renovated units represents clear rent growth opportunity; unit-level upgrades should drive 8–12% NOI accretion once amortized across the portfolio.

AI analysis · Updated 21 days ago

/

AI Analysis

Location Profile Supports Urban-Oriented Positioning, Though Transit Dependency Risk Exists

Fitzhugh Urban Flats' Walk Score of 73 ("Very Walkable") and Bike Score of 65 indicate genuine pedestrian/micro-mobility viability—a meaningful asset in Dallas where most multifamily trades on car dependency. However, the Transit Score of 57 ("Good Transit") is the constraint: this falls below the 70+ threshold preferred by transit-dependent renters and suggests the property relies on a hybrid tenant base that owns or uses personal vehicles. Without the average rent, we cannot validate whether the location premium justifies pricing relative to comparable suburban Dallas assets, but the walkability credentials position this 176-unit asset for the young professional/small household segment—if rent remains disciplined versus truly transit-rich Dallas submarkets.

AI analysis · Updated 21 days ago
Distance Name Category
📍 2.4 miles from Downtown Dallas
Map Notes

No notes yet

The 56-unit pipeline represents 31.8% of Fitzhugh Urban Flats' 176-unit inventory—a material competitive threat in a submarket already experiencing deteriorating vacancy. Most concerning: nine of 15 nearby permits remain in early-stage review (revisions required, plan review, or additional info needed), suggesting staggered deliveries through 2026-27 rather than simultaneous supply shock, which extends downward pressure on rent growth. The scattered geographic distribution across East Dallas submarkets indicates these are direct competitors rather than alternative neighborhoods, amplifying displacement risk for this 176-unit asset.

AI analysis · Updated 21 days ago
🏗️ 56 permits within 3 mi
32% pipeline
Distance Address Description Status Filed
0.2 mi 4609 MANETT ST QTEAM MEETING 8.12.2025 (1:30 PM) new townhomes Revisions Required Jun 17, 2025
0.6 mi 4704 MONARCH ST Multifamily New Construction, 8 townhouses with 2 bedrooms Inspection Phase Apr 01, 2025
0.7 mi 1906 MOSER AVE QTEAM MEETING 3.10.2026 (All Day) new multifamily constru... Revisions Required Jan 20, 2026
0.7 mi 1722 N FITZHUGH AVE 5 Townhome Units New Construction (Multifamily) Plan Review Dec 10, 2025
0.7 mi 1902 N CARROLL AVE New Construction of 3 story 33 townhouses with garage at ... Inspection Phase Jul 01, 2022
0.7 mi 4555 TRAVIS ST QTEAM PROJECT The project is a mixed use project of appro... Revisions Required Aug 26, 2022
0.8 mi 4777 N CENTRAL EXPY New podium structured multifamily building with below gra... Inspection Phase Jul 02, 2024
0.9 mi 4315 SAN JACINTO ST New construction of 9 units multifamily Payment Due Sep 17, 2024
0.9 mi 4319 SAN JACINTO ST New Construction 9 unit multifamily. Inspection Phase Sep 17, 2024
0.9 mi 1714 RIPLEY ST New construction of five townhomes. Inspection Phase Jun 19, 2024
0.9 mi 1717 N PEAK ST Commercial New construction of a 7-unit multi-family buil... Payment Due Feb 27, 2025
1.0 mi 4405 SCURRY ST Q-Team 4405 Scurry for a New, Commercial Multifamily deve... Revisions Required Nov 20, 2024
1.0 mi 4475 SCURRY ST New Construction of 18 unit Multifamily. Inspection Phase Oct 11, 2024
1.0 mi 4918 BRYAN ST New construction MFD, 7 dwelling units, 4918 Bryan Inspection Phase Jun 02, 2023
1.0 mi 5731 RICHMOND AVE QTEAM MEETING 10.21.2025 (AM) New construction of six-uni... Inspection Phase Sep 23, 2025
1.0 mi 4320 SCURRY ST Q Team for East Village II New Construction for 3 buildin... Inspection Phase May 19, 2022
1.0 mi 4315 SCURRY ST Q Team review for East Village New Construction for 15 -... Inspection Phase May 04, 2022
1.1 mi 5115 MCKINNEY AVE New construction of mixed use building.90 multifamily uni... Plan Review Jul 16, 2023
1.1 mi 5601 BRYAN PKWY QTEAM MEETING 9.3.2025 AM To build 5 unit condos - Total ... Inspection Phase Jun 30, 2025
1.1 mi 1255 ANNEX AVE QTEAM MEETING 1.8.26 (1:30 PM) New Construction - Multifa... Inspection Phase Nov 24, 2025
1.2 mi 3900 LEMMON AVE New construction of MFD project. 406 dwelling units with ... Revisions Required Aug 21, 2024
1.2 mi 3608 SAN JACINTO ST New residential townhomes Inspection Phase May 26, 2022
1.3 mi 6001 LEWIS ST Commercial New - Multifamily Inspection Phase Feb 08, 2024
1.3 mi 3555 DICKASON AVE Q-Team Migrated NEW 4 LEVEL ABOVE GRADE GARAGE(1-3.5).LEV... Payment Due Mar 24, 2021
1.3 mi 6027 LA VISTA DR Construct 5 Plex WOOD FRAMESTUCCO/SIDINGCONDOS WITH ATTAC... Revisions Required Sep 19, 2025
1.3 mi 5946 LEWIS ST Building 5 condos -3 story. Revisions Required Aug 15, 2025
1.4 mi 1000 N PEAK ST QTEAM 1000 N Peak. New Construction of 54-unit, 3-story M... Revisions Required May 15, 2025
1.4 mi 2702 MCKINNEY AVE 2700 McKinney - 21 Story Mixed Use Tower Including Retail... Payment Due Jun 09, 2022
1.4 mi 4013 N HALL ST QTEAM MEETING 7.17.2025 8 unit multifamily new construction Payment Due Jun 17, 2025
1.4 mi 4011 N HALL ST QTEAM MEETING 7.22.2025 - 8 unit multifamily new construc... Payment Due Jun 17, 2025
1.4 mi 4005 N HALL ST QTEAM MEETING - 7.23.2025 - 8 unit multifamily new constr... Payment Due Jun 17, 2025
1.4 mi 5705 LIVE OAK ST New Construction Multifamily-5705 Live Oak Inspection Phase Jul 24, 2024
1.6 mi 6151 ORAM ST Construction of New Multifamily Units Permit About to Expire Dec 23, 2024
1.6 mi 4330 DICKASON AVE New construction of multi-family// 4330 Dickason. Plan Review Jun 29, 2022
1.6 mi 2505 TURTLE CREEK BLVD New construction of 20-story assisted living building wit... Inspection Phase Aug 06, 2024
1.7 mi 6235 ORAM ST QTEAM MEETING 1.29.2026 (9AM) 40 unit, 4 story apartment ... Plan Review Jan 12, 2026
1.8 mi 4618 COLUMBIA AVE Multifamily-2 New Duplex Application About to Expire Dec 16, 2021
1.8 mi 3031 N HARWOOD ST QTEAM MEETING 9.4.2025 3131 N Harwood For Office and 303... Revisions Required Jul 21, 2025
1.9 mi 4918 EAST SIDE AVE New construction of 5-unit townhome building Application About to Expire Jun 28, 2024
1.9 mi 2314 ARROYO AVE he proposed work includes the construction of three-story... In Review Sep 16, 2025
1.9 mi 2811 HONDO AVE New construction of 12 unit townhome on two lots; 6 units... Inspection Phase Jul 16, 2021
1.9 mi 2723 HONDO AVE New construction, multifamily.6 dwelling units. Inspection Phase Nov 27, 2024
2.0 mi 3201 MAIN ST QTEAM MEETING 12.3.2025 - NOT USING SB840, CONFIRMED WITH... Application About to Expire Oct 16, 2025
2.0 mi 5810 REIGER AVE QTEAM MEETING 11.20.2025 (9 am) New construction of group... Inspection Phase Oct 23, 2025
2.1 mi 2514 LUCAS DR (1131) MULTI-FAMILY DWELLING / 5 UNIT MULTIFAMILY Inspection Phase Feb 24, 2025
2.3 mi 2013 JACKSON ST ***Manual Recreation*** 1906051126*** - New Multifamily C... Inspection Phase Jul 10, 2025
2.3 mi 4501 AFTON ST Residential use Inspection Phase Nov 23, 2021
2.4 mi 720 S GOOD LATIMER EXPY Q Team Review New construction of a 21 level residential ... Plan Review Jan 31, 2023
2.5 mi 3501 ASH LN New 293 units apartment complex with wrapping 5 story par... Revisions Required Aug 05, 2023
2.5 mi 3700 INWOOD RD QTEAM MEETING Senior Living community with independent li... Inspection Phase May 28, 2025
2.5 mi 1701 S MALCOLM X BLVD Q-Team Review, new Construction of two-story structure co... Inspection Phase Nov 18, 2021
2.8 mi 2522 MERLIN ST NEW CONSTRUCCION MULTIFAMILY Additional Info Required Mar 09, 2026
2.9 mi 1919 S HARWOOD ST QTEAM MEETING 1.29.2026 (1:30 PM) 4 story multifamily apa... Revisions Required Dec 29, 2025
2.9 mi 1905 CORINTH ST QTEAM MEETING 11.6.2025 (1:30 PM) Two four story multifam... Revisions Required Sep 19, 2025
2.9 mi 2095 S HARWOOD ST THE PROJECT CONSISTS OF NEW CONSTRUCTION IMPROVEMENTS FOR... Payment Due Jul 18, 2023
3.0 mi 1819 LEAR ST PROJECT CONSIST OF (2) 5 UNIT 4-STORY NEW CONSTRUCTION TO... Revisions Required Nov 24, 2025
Nearby Construction Notes

No notes yet

Debt & Transaction History

Refinancing risk and leverage structure suggest near-term seller motivation. The property carries $177.3M in total debt against a $40.5M appraised value and $87.9M estimated sale price—a debt-to-unit ratio of $1.01M, indicating aggressive leverage. The 2017 Walker & Dunlop loan (84-month term, originated Sept 2022) matures in ~2025, while the dual 2020 MISC INS tranches ($61.5M each, one with 36-month term) likely already require attention; absent rate/maturity details, refinancing at current market rates would materially pressure cash flow. The rapid ownership churn—six transactions in 17 years including a 2010 quit-claim deed (distress signal) and 2017 tax deed acquisition by GS—combined with absentee corporate ownership since 2020, suggests repositioning play rather than stabilized hold, and the widening gap between appraised value ($40.5M) and sale price assumption ($87.9M) warrants scrutiny on that valuation basis.

AI analysis · Updated 21 days ago
Ownership Duration
6.2 years
Since Jan 2020
Transactions
6 recorded
Owner Type
Company
Absentee owner
Owner Mailing Address
100 PARK AVE # 3500, NEW YORK, NY 10017-5516

🏛️ TX Comptroller Entity Data

Beneficial Owner
Benjamin Friedman high
via officer match
Registered Agent
Corporation Service Company D/B/A Csc Lawyers Inco
211 E. 7TH STREET, SUITE 620, AUSTIN, TX, 78701
Officers / Directors
Benjamin Friedman — President
Entity Mailing Address
211 E 7TH ST STE 620, AUSTIN, TX, 78701
State of Formation
DE
SOS Status
ACTIVE
Current Lender
Miscellaneous Ins Co
Loan Amount
$61,500,000 ($349,432/unit)
Maturity Date
Not recorded
Loan Type
Unknown
January 16, 2020 Stand Alone Finance Deed of Trust
Buyer: Gs Fitzhugh Project Owner Llc, via First American Title Ins Co Na
Miscellaneous Ins Co $61,500,000 Senior Term: 3yr
January 16, 2020 Resale Grant Deed
Buyer: 2707 North Fitzhugh Avenue Lp, from Gs Fitzhugh Project Owner Llc via Attorney Only
Sale price: $76,875,000
Miscellaneous Ins Co $61,500,000 Senior
September 22, 2017 Resale Tax Deed
Buyer: Gs Fitzhugh Project Owner Llc, from Residl Fitzhugh Reit Monogram via Attorney Only
Sale price: $67,887,500
Walker & Dunlop $54,310,000 Senior Term: 7yr
July 23, 2010 Stand Alone Finance Deed of Trust
Buyer: Harvard Fitzhugh Rei Behringer,
June 15, 2010 Nominal/Quit Claim Quit Claim Deed
Buyer: Harvard Fitzhugh Rei Behringer, from Fitzhugh Apartments Lp via Other
October 20, 2006 Resale Grant Deed
Buyer: Fitzhugh Apartments, from Homer Alcott via Chicago Title Insurance Compan
Debt Notes

No notes yet

Financial Estimates

Estimated from loan records, rental listings, and appraisal data using industry-standard assumptions.

Sale & Valuation

Est. Sale Price
$87,857,143
Sale $/Unit
$499,188
Value YoY
+14.3%
Implied Cap Rate
Est. Cap Rate

Operating Income

Gross Potential Rent
Est. Vacancy
Submarket Vac.
6.2%
Eff. Gross Income
OpEx Ratio
45%
Est. NOI
NOI/Unit

Debt & Taxes

Taxes/Unit
$5,754/yr
Est. DSCR

Based on most recent loan: $61,500,000 (Jan 2020, attom)

Submarket Benchmarks

📊

Computed from nearby properties within 3 miles of similar vintage

Submarket Cap Rate
5.27%
Price/Unit Benchmark
$192,698
Property: $499,188 (↑159%)
Rent/SF
$2.25/sf
Financial Estimates Notes

No notes yet

Property Summary

Fitzhugh Urban Flats is a 176-unit garden-style apartment built in 2007 with brick exterior and wood-frame construction across three stories. The 179K SF property carries "Good" quality and "Excellent" condition ratings, with 165.975K SF of net leasable area. Located in Dallas with a Walk Score of 73, the asset commands a 4.2 Google rating. Parking configuration, unit finishes, utilities, and pet policies are not specified in available data.

AI analysis · Updated 21 days ago

Property Details

Account #
00200100140010000
Market
Dallas County, TX
Building Class
APARTMENT (BRICK EXTERIOR)
Building Style
Garden
Construction
D-WOOD FRAME
Quality
GOOD
Condition
EXCELLENT
Stories
3
Gross Building Area
179,000 SF
Net Leasable Area
165,975 SF
Neighborhood
UNASSIGNED
Last Sale
June 20, 2024
Business Status
Operational
Enriched
about 2 months ago

Owner Information

Owner
OAMA FITZHUGH LLC
Mailing Address
NEW YORK, NEW YORK 100175516
Property Notes

No notes yet

Rental Notes

No notes yet

Demographics

Fitzhugh Urban Flats sits in a high-income urban core with severe affordability constraints that will limit rent growth without unit repositioning. The 1-mile radius shows $103.9K median household income against a 22.0% affordability ratio—meaning rents already consume roughly one-fifth of area incomes, leaving minimal upside before pricing out the local renter base. However, the 74.3% renter concentration within 1-mile and skewed income distribution (33.1% earning $150K+) indicate strong demand from affluent renters willing to pay premium for urban proximity, offsetting thin middle-market depth. The 3-mile radius reveals a critical expansion opportunity: $120.3K median income, lower 18.9% affordability ratio, and 97.4K households create a deeper addressable market with more pricing flexibility, suggesting the property's value lies in capturing commute-shed demand rather than relying on immediate neighborhood saturation.

AI analysis · Updated 21 days ago

1-Mile Radius

Population
33,971
Households
20,460
Avg Household Size
1.68
Median HH Income
$103,982
Median Home Value
$457,791
Median Rent
$1,910
% Renter Occupied
74.3%
Affordability
22.0% (rent/income)
Income Distribution
<$25k $150k+

3-Mile Radius

Population
180,528
Households
97,359
Avg Household Size
1.94
Median HH Income
$120,300
Median Home Value
$664,075
Median Rent
$1,891
% Renter Occupied
67.3%
Affordability
18.9% (rent/income)
Income Distribution
<$25k $150k+

5-Mile Radius

Population
380,581
Households
183,903
Avg Household Size
2.14
Median HH Income
$104,678
Median Home Value
$528,592
Median Rent
$1,696
% Renter Occupied
63.5%
Affordability
19.4% (rent/income)
Income Distribution
<$25k $150k+

Source: US Census ACS 5-Year Estimates (2023) · 13 tracts (1mi)

Demographics Notes

No notes yet

Unit Mix Notes

No notes yet

Amenities Notes

No notes yet

Appraisal History

Appraisal & Value Analysis

Current appraised value of $40.5M ($230.1K/unit) reflects strong 14.3% YoY appreciation, though limited historical data prevents trend assessment. Land represents 27.2% of total value ($11.0M), leaving 72.8% in improvements—a typical stack for a 2007 vintage asset that suggests limited redevelopment upside without significant value destruction. Single-year snapshot insufficient to distinguish market-driven strength from cyclical peak; prior years' appraisals needed to confirm whether 14.3% growth is momentum or correction.

AI analysis · Updated 21 days ago
Year Total Value Change
2025 $40,505,340 +14.3%
Appraisal Notes

No notes yet

Reviews Notes

No notes yet

Sources Notes

No notes yet