4219 CLUBHOUSE CIR, IRVING, TX, 75038
$29,340,010
2025 Appraised Value
↑ 0.0% from prior year
Primary Signal: Severe debt-to-value disconnect ($5.5K/unit on $29.3M valuation) indicates either data quality issues or distressed capital structure masking underlying weakness. The property's fundamental challenge is demographic–trapped in a 1-mile radius where 36.4% of households earn under $50K and 82.5% rent by necessity, not preference, while higher-income competitive renters cluster 3+ miles out. At $163.0K/unit appraised value with flat year-over-year movement and zero near-term supply relief, the asset is entirely dependent on occupancy recovery rather than rent growth or scarcity premium. The car-dependent location (Walk Score 22) and 8.6-year hold under absentee ownership suggest prior exit windows were missed; refinancing risk is material given minimal leverage cushion and undisclosed loan maturity. Pass unless acquisition price reflects significant discount to appraised value and pro forma assumes lease-up rather than rate expansion.
No notes yet
No notes yet
This car-dependent location (Walk Score 22, Transit Score 26) severely limits tenant appeal beyond workforce housing and car owners, undercutting any premium positioning. Irving's sprawl pattern and weak transit infrastructure mean residents face 15-25 minute commutes to DFW employment centers, which trades off against affordability rather than supporting elevated rents. The amenity desert and transit constraints suggest this 180-unit asset targets essential workforce and secondary market renters—deal attractiveness hinges entirely on acquisition price and cap rate relative to comparable Irving properties, not location premium.
No notes yet
Supply Pipeline Analysis
Zero near-term supply pressure—no construction within competitive radius and pipeline represents 0.0% of the 180-unit asset. However, deteriorating submarket vacancy trends suggest demand softness independent of new supply; rent growth will depend on broader market stabilization rather than supply scarcity. The absence of competing deliveries is favorable for hold periods but doesn't offset existing occupancy headwinds.
No multifamily construction permits found within 3 miles
No notes yet
Key Takeaway: Severely mismatched debt-to-value structure signals distressed asset or data quality issue.
The $0.994M loan against a $29.3M appraised value yields only $5.5K per unit of debt—extraordinarily low leverage even for stabilized multifamily, suggesting either (1) the loan is partial/subordinate financing not captured in full, or (2) the appraisal is inflated relative to actual underwriting. DSCR is unmeasurable without rate and payment data. The Housing Authority of Dallas's ownership from 2006–2017 followed by LB II Holdings' acquisition in August 2017 represents an institutional-to-private transition; six transactions in 18 years indicates portfolio churning rather than a buy-and-hold strategy. Current 8.6-year hold with absentee company ownership and missing loan maturity/rate details obscures refinancing risk, but the minimal debt-to-value cushion leaves little room for rate stress if refinance is imminent.
No notes yet
Estimated from loan records, rental listings, and appraisal data using industry-standard assumptions.
Based on most recent loan: $994,000 (Aug 2017, attom)
Computed from nearby properties within 3 miles of similar vintage
No notes yet
Reserve @ Las Brisas Ph II is a 180-unit garden-style apartment community built in 2005 with brick exterior and wood-frame construction across three stories, delivering 200.8K SF of net leasable area. Rated in excellent quality with good physical condition, the property lacks defined parking details and amenities data in the record. Located in Irving with a walk score of 22, indicating car-dependent accessibility. No utility inclusions or pet policy restrictions are documented.
No notes yet
No notes yet
Affordability Risk & Submarket Mismatch: The 1-mile submarket—where this property sits—presents a fundamental underwriting challenge. Median household income of $59.7K against an affordability ratio of 27.8% suggests rent levels are calibrated for the broader 3-5 mile ring ($80K+ income, 21.8-22.3% ratios), not the immediate neighborhood. The immediate 1-mile radius is workforce housing territory: 36.4% of households earn under $50K, yet 82.5% are renters, indicating trapped demand with limited purchasing power. Demand Depth vs. Pricing Power: While the 82.5% renter concentration in the 1-mile radius signals strong renter market presence, it's driven by necessity, not preference—this cohort cannot afford to own. As submarket income rises sharply at the 3-mile threshold (+$20.7K), the property sits in a valuation gap between lower-income immediate residents and higher-income peripheral competition. Growth & Demographic Support: Population growth appears modest and diffuse across rings, with minimal income skew toward affluent renters (9.9% earning $150K+ locally vs. 17.3-18.5% at 3-5 miles). This geometry—strong local renter concentration but weak local income—signals the asset depends on lease-up and occupancy more than rental rate expansion.
Source: US Census ACS 5-Year Estimates (2023) · 6 tracts (1mi)
No notes yet
No notes yet
No notes yet
Appraisal Analysis: RESERVE @ LAS BRISAS PH II
The property holds a flat valuation at $29.3M ($163.0K/unit) with zero year-over-year movement, suggesting either a recent stabilization after prior volatility or a static appraisal cycle. The improvement-to-land ratio of 90.2% to 9.8% reflects a fully-built, mature asset with minimal redevelopment upside—land value of $2.9M constrains any meaningful repositioning economics. Without prior-year comparables, we cannot assess whether the 2025 appraisal represents market repricing or rental growth, but the heavy weighting toward improvements indicates value is entirely contingent on NOI performance rather than land appreciation.
| Year | Total Value | Change |
|---|---|---|
| 2025 | $29,340,010 | +0.0% |
No notes yet
No notes yet
No notes yet